Sierra Nevada forests are losing plant diversity due to high-severity fires, according to a study from the University of California, Davis. These fires are turning patches of forest into shrub fields â€” indefinitely, in some cases.
For the study, published in the journal Ecosphere, scientists analyzed plant diversity across a spectrum of fire severity â€” from low to moderate to high. They found the sweet spot for plant diversity exists where tree stands burned with low-to-moderate severity, as mixed conifer forests did in this region for millennia before the imposition of fire suppression policies in the early 20th century. Such policies have greatly increased forest density and the amount of woody fuels in many California forests and led to more severe, stand-replacing fires.
On the extreme ends of the spectrum, unburned areas and high-severity burn areas showed relatively low plant diversity. Five to 10 years or more after experiencing high-severity burns, many forest stands were replaced by shrub fields that supported few plant species.
â€˜A different kind of fireâ€™
The results suggest these forests, which are used to living with and even benefiting from fire, have not yet adapted to this newer regime of intense, high-severity fires.
â€œThis system is experiencing a different kind of fire,â€� said lead author Clark Richter, a doctoral candidate at UC Davis. â€œThe species are outside of their limits. More high-severity fires greatly change a diverse and highly varied forest to one where all the trees are dead and whatâ€™s left is often just a few species of shrub, not the herbs and wildflowers you may be used to seeing.â€�
The researchers examined postfire plant response in eight areas of yellow pine and mixed conifer forests that burned in Californiaâ€™s Sierra Nevada between 2001 and 2012. These areas have experienced among the biggest increases in wildfire size and severity over the past 30 years in the continental United States. The areas stretched from the site of the Moonlight Fire (2007) in Lassen County southward to the Power Fire (2004) in Amador County.
Climate, current trends call for multipronged approach
The study states that under climate change and current fire trends, â€œthere is a real possibility that large portions of the Sierra Nevada landscape could be caught in a feedback-loopâ€� that prevents recovery of former forest.
â€œWe will need enhanced management tools and resources to help forests adapt if we want to preserve plant diversity for soil, animal and ecosystem health,â€� Richter said.
The paper suggests a multifaceted management approach that combines forest thinning with a major expansion of prescribed burning and allowing naturally ignited fires to burn under moderate weather conditions.
Additional co-authors include co-leading and senior author Marcel RejmÃ¡nek from the UC Davis Department of Evolution and Ecology, Jesse E.D. Miller from Stanford University, Kevin Welch from the UC Davis Department of Plant Sciences, JonahMaria Weeks from the UC Davis Department of Environmental Science and Policy, and Hugh Safford from UC Davis and the USDA Forest Service.
The study was funded by the USDA Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region and the Eldorado National Forest.